Battle of the Big Bands Revives a Time-Honored Tradition

Come see the Battle of the Big Bands!

News | Nov, 10th 2016

When Sammy Miller and Evan Sherman bring their big bands to the Appel Room this weekend for a battle royale, they'll be bringing quite a bit of history with them.

The shows will showcase two bandleaders most familiar from their work hosting Dizzy's Club Coca-Cola Late Night Sessions as well as many of New York's most promising young jazz musicians. They'll also hearken back to a tradition of rivalry that's been with jazz ever since its beginnings.

Jazz musicians in general are not exactly non-competitive; the "cutting contest" is not a new concept. In turn-of-the-century New Orleans, trumpet players vied for dominance at battles held in Storyville clubs. Throughout the 1920s, stride pianists took part in competitions where they'd try to play each other off the stage—James P. Johnson and Willie "The Lion" Smith took part in a number of friendly cutting contests in New York.

But these battles grew in scale once big bands got involved. Harlem's famed Savoy Ballroom, formerly located between 140th and 141st Streets on Lenox Ave., was ground zero for these historic events. The first such confrontation is generally agreed to have been the "Battle of Jazz," which took place on May 15, 1927, and featured bands led by Chick Webb, Fletcher Henderson, Fess Williams, and King Oliver. 

Over the next decade, the Savoy hosted a number of additional battles, many of which featured Webb's ensemble (also the Savoy's house band). All were adjudicated by hugely appreciative audiences, who flocked to the shows and lined up around the block to get in. Webb mostly held his own, defeating Fletcher Henderson in 1937 and then the Benny Goodman Orchestra in one of the most famous battles, held in 1938. He also battled the Count Basie Orchestra to a draw (though some maintain Webb was victorious) on another jam-packed night that featured Ella Fitzgerald, Billie Holiday, and a solo Duke Ellington. However, it's generally agreed upon that Webb's band was blown off the bandstand by Ellington's orchestra when they battled in 1937. "We tore them up, man," Ellington drummer Sonny Greer later told an interviewer.

That was the golden age of the big band battle, but musicians have done their best to carry on tradition. The Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra with Wynton Marsalis has engaged in its fair share of skirmishes, including last year's "Battle Royale" in Chicago with the Legendary Count Basie Orchestra. They also battled the Clayton-Hamilton Jazz Orchestra back in 2008's Big Band Bash. 

Listen: Another Big Band Bash: Jazz At Lincoln Center Orchestra & Clayton-Hamilton Jazz Orchestra 

On Friday and Saturday nights, Sherman and Miller will put on a fiery big band battle of their own, employing comedy, friendly one-upmanship, and high-velocity virtuosity, and audiences will get a taste of a bygone era when such battles were commonplace.

Don't miss The Battle of the Big Bands this Friday, 11/11 and Saturday 11/12 in the Appel Room!


Sammy Miller & The Congregation

Saxophones: Patrick Bartley, Patrick Sargent, Ben Flocks, Camille Thurman, Dan White

Trombones: Sam Crittenden, Mariel Bildsten, Andy Clausen

Trumpets: Jumaane Smith, Enrique Sanchez, Alphonso Horne, Riley Mulherkar

Bass: John Snow

Piano: Dave Linard

Drums: Sammy Miller

Evan Sherman Big Band

Saxophones: Julian Lee, Immanuel Wilkins, Stacy Dillard, Jerry Weldon, Dean Tsur

Trombones: Corey Wilcox, Frank Lacy, Coleman Hughes

Trumpets: Brian Pareschi, Pete Desiena, Bruce Harris, James Zollar

Bass: Ben Wolfe

Piano: Joel Wenhardt

Vibraphone: Joel Ross

Drums: Evan Sherman

read more

One of the great impresarios in American musical history, George Wein discusses the origins of his Newport Jazz Festival and how its first occurrence in 1954 sought to bridge a deepening rift in the jazz community.

read more

No jazz record collection is complete without these classic records! Learn more about historic recordings from Wayne Shorter, Betty Carter, and more!


Duke Ellington

The Essential Ellington: How Duke Ellington Changed Jazz Forever

Nobody in the history of jazz expressed himself more freely; or with more variety, swing, and sophistication than Duke Ellington. Listen to our playlist of essential Ellington recordings and find out how he changed jazz forever.

read more
Nina and Nat

And the Inductees Are… Your Choices for the Ertegun Jazz Hall of Fame

Find out who the three 2018 inductees into the Ertegun Jazz Hall of Fame are! All three made an indelible impact on America's music and influenced millions in the process.

read more
Ahmad Jamal - Photo by Frank Stewart for Jazz at Lincoln Center

Another 10 Essential Jazz Albums

Here's a list of 10 more must-have classics for to round out your collection of jazz records.

read more
Thelonious Monk at the 1965 Newport Jazz Festival with his children, T.S. and Boo Boo.

10 Things You Didn't Know About Thelonious Monk, by His Son T.S. Monk

Celebrate Thelonious Monk’s Centennial by getting to know the legend through his son’s memories.

read more
Chick Corea - photo by Frank Stewart for Jazz at Lincoln Center

Chick Corea: Five Essential Albums

Chick Corea is one of the most influential figures in jazz and one of the greatest living jazz pianists. In advance of his trio’s July 4 performance in Highland Park, IL, at the Ravinia Festival alongside the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra, here are five essential albums from his discography.

read more
Wynton Marsalis performs on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Celebrating Spaces and The Abyssinian Mass with Colbert on The Late Show

Wynton Marsalis appeared on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert to perform with Jon Batiste, Stay Human, and acclaimed dancer Lil Buck. Check out video and behind-the-scenes content from their performance.

read more

10 Essential Jazz Albums

New to jazz and don't know where to start? With many artists and extensive catalogues of music, a new jazz listener can feel intimidated. We're here to help! Check out our list of 10 albums to get you started on your jazz journey and introduce yourself to some of jazz's great artists.

read more

A Visit to Clark Terry

On December 7, 2014 the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra drove 8 hours on an off day to play for Clark Terry on his 94th birthday. Victor Goines, James Chirillo, Ted Nash, Vincent Gardner, and Walter Blanding recall the day and the impact that Clark had on jazz.

read more


Ornette Coleman

The Department Store Painting that Inspired Ornette Coleman and 5 Other Interesting Facts About His Life

Ornette Coleman led a life as fascinating as his music. Read up on some interesting facts about this jazz legend!

read more
Joe Temperley, by Frank Stewart for Jazz at Lincoln Center

Notes from the Road: Remembering Joe Temperley

Before his passing in May, Joe Temperley spent 29 unforgettable years as the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra's baritone saxophonist and its beloved elder statesman. Between performances on their recent mini-tour of Canada, several JLCO members shared their memories of Temperley, who left behind an indelible legacy and a whole lot of stories.

read more

6 Underappreciated Jazz Artists You Should Check Out

April is Jazz Appreciation Month, so we thought we'd celebrate by delving into the careers of a handful of underappreciated jazz artists. Explore the careers of six musicians who deserve more accolades and learn the best places to start with their discographies.

read more