"Just Another Night": Remembering Benny Goodman's Epochal Carnegie Hall Concert

Benny Goodman

News | Jan, 3rd 2018

It's been nearly 80 years since Benny Goodman’s legendary 1938 debut at Carnegie Hall, a milestone that the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra with Wynton Marsalis will celebrate with a series of concerts Jan 11-13. (You can alsowatch a live, free webcast of the Jan 13 concert!) To discuss the concert's historical import, we brought together Gino Francesconi, Director of the Archives and Rose Museum at Carnegie Hall, and Loren Schoenberg, who in addition to being a Swing University teacher is the founding director of The National Jazz Museum in Harlem and creator of the last Benny Goodman Orchestra. Schoenberg will teach The Life and Legacy of Benny Goodman at Swing University beginning January 31. Click hereto learn more.

Gino Francesconi: Of all of Carnegie Hall’s 50,000 concerts, there are a handful that stand out as “legendary.” Certainly the January 16, 1938 Benny Goodman concert is one of those. Our history of jazz goes back to James Reese Europe. The Benny Goodman concert stands out because it was one of the first times that people bought tickets to actually sit and listen to swing and not dance to it. It was one of the first times blacks and whites played together on a concert stage. The recording that Benny put in a closet and forgot about for 20 years—at the time of its release, it was one of the bestselling LP sets of all time. It helped cement the live recording.

Loren Schoenberg: When I was working for Benny he was lobbying Teo Macero very hard... who at that time was at CBS. Benny wanted the Carnegie Hall album to come out as one of the first CDs. We had many lunches with Teo, who at the time was producing. We couldn’t get any traction. One day Benny called me and said, “On your way into work today"—I was his personal manager at the time—"I want you to pick up something at Murray's Sturgeon Shop.” It’s kind of like a version of Zabar’s. He said, “Go to Murray’s Sturgeon Shop and they will tell you what to do.” I had no idea what was going to happen. So, I go to Murray’s Sturgeon Shop and I pick up two heavy bags full of lox and white fish and all this kind of stuff and there’s a note on it: “To be delivered to William S. Paley.” William S. Paley was the founder of CBS. I take it down to that Black Rock building and it says: “From Benny Goodman”—and I’m actually put into a private elevator that was only for Mr. Paley and people who work on the top floor. I take it up and deliver 20 pounds' worth of Murray’s food to Paley’s office. I didn’t see him. But about a week later we found out the album was coming out on CD. [Laughs]

One of the things that make the concert so important was because the same night as the Benny Goodman Carnegie Hall concert, Count Basie’s band was going to battle Chick Webb up at the Savoy. And Goodman had just reached the pinnacle of his commercial success right in the year of 1937. All these radio executives that were producing the Camel Caravan got together with this idea which is: “How do we play Benny Goodman?”

GF: They weren’t sure how the audience was going to react [to Benny playing Carnegie Hall] or if anybody was even going to show up.

LS: Well he wasn’t sure. Benny wasn’t sure. 

GF: And then the story was that they hired a well-known comedian from the time, Beatrice Lillie, to just sort of hang out and wait in case the audience got unruly... she’d go out and tame them down. But it never got that far. The concert sold out. We only had two box-office windows at the time and people lined up. It was incredible. Tickets were gone in about two and a half hours and the story I’ve been told is that Benny had to buy tickets for his family members from scalpers outside.

LS: I think with Bea Lillie it was Benny's concern that he didn’t think the band in and of itself playing music that was primarily dance music would suffice, so he wanted to have some entertainment there. He thought they should have a comedian because they were on stage.

Jazz at Lincoln Center: What made this show so different?

LS: The words: “Carnegie Hall.”

GF: It was funny because the audience showed up—they were all classical music-goers—and they just wanted to see what all of this was about. But there were a lot of Benny followers around. It’s one of the rarest recordings we have in the archives. We only have one copy [of the program].

LS: Which is funny because "4 million people were there." (Laughs)


Watch the JLCO's performance of Benny Goodman: King of Swing live this Jan 13 at 8pm EST!


All images by William P. Gottlieb. Courtesy of the William P. Gottlieb/Ira and Leonore S. Gershwin Fund Collection, Music Division, Library of Congress.

read more

Here's a list of 10 more must-have classics for to round out your collection of jazz records.

read more

Need some help ringing in the holidays? Queue up our holiday content and enjoy!


Dianne Reeves's V-Day Mixtape

A hand-picked list of songs for "late-into-the-night, romantic rendezvous" courtesy five-time Grammy Award-winner Dianne Reeves. Featuring Nina Simone, Geri Allen, Al Green, and many more!

read more
Study up on jazz piano history!

Playlist: Get Ready for Handful of Keys with the Evolution of Jazz Piano!

Study up for the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra with Wynton Marsalis's new album Handful of Keys, featuring special guests Joey Alexander, Dick Hyman, Myra Melford, and more!

read more
Listen to a playlist featuring some of John Lewis's greatest music!

Playlist: Get to Know

Enrich your listening experience of "The Music of John Lewis," the new album from the JLCO with Wynton Marsalis ft. Jon Batiste, with an excerpt from its liner notes and a playlist exploring Lewis's oeuvre!

read more
Ingrid Jensen in RECOLLECT

Crate-dig with Jimmy Cobb, Sheila Jordan & more in RECOLLECT

Our new original video series RECOLLECT takes you record shopping with some of the world's greatest jazz artists, including Jimmy Cobb, Ron Carter, Sheila Jordan, and many more!

read more
Chick Corea - photo by Frank Stewart for Jazz at Lincoln Center

Chick Corea: Five Essential Albums

Chick Corea is one of the most influential figures in jazz and one of the greatest living jazz pianists. In advance of his trio’s July 4 performance in Highland Park, IL, at the Ravinia Festival alongside the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra, here are five essential albums from his discography.

read more
Wynton Marsalis performs on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Celebrating Spaces and The Abyssinian Mass with Colbert on The Late Show

Wynton Marsalis appeared on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert to perform with Jon Batiste, Stay Human, and acclaimed dancer Lil Buck. Check out video and behind-the-scenes content from their performance.

read more

10 Essential Jazz Albums

New to jazz and don't know where to start? With many artists and extensive catalogues of music, a new jazz listener can feel intimidated. We're here to help! Check out our list of 10 albums to get you started on your jazz journey and introduce yourself to some of jazz's great artists.

read more

A Visit to Clark Terry

On December 7, 2014 the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra drove 8 hours on an off day to play for Clark Terry on his 94th birthday. Victor Goines, James Chirillo, Ted Nash, Vincent Gardner, and Walter Blanding recall the day and the impact that Clark had on jazz.

read more


Watch Helen Sung and Isaiah J. Thompson perform Handful of Keys live!

To celebrate the latest release from Blue Engine records, two world-class jazz pianists showed off their chops live from Paste Magazine's NYC studios.

read more
Grassella Oliphant

Lessons from Our Masters: Grassella Oliphant on Keeping Jazz's Legacy Alive

Grassella Oliphant kicks off the Lessons from Our Masters series on his 88th birthday, opening our Coca-Cola Generations in Jazz Festival. Oliphant played with Ahmad Jamal in 1952, Sarah Vaughan through the late 1950s, and released acclaimed albums featuring heavyweights like Bobby Hutcherson, Clark Terry, and Grant Green. It’ll be a festive evening of music as we celebrate Oliphant’s birthday and launch our 2017 Coca-Cola Generations in Jazz Festival!

read more
Buddy Rich

So the Story Goes: Buddy Rich on Music and Magic

In the latest installment of So the Story Goes, Buddy Rich—sometimes regarded as "the world's greatest drummer"—gets rhapsodic about the power of music and recounts that one time he played for the Queen of England.

read more
Joe Temperley, by Frank Stewart for Jazz at Lincoln Center

Notes from the Road: Remembering Joe Temperley

Before his passing in May, Joe Temperley spent 29 unforgettable years as the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra's baritone saxophonist and its beloved elder statesman. Between performances on their recent mini-tour of Canada, several JLCO members shared their memories of Temperley, who left behind an indelible legacy and a whole lot of stories.

read more

6 Underappreciated Jazz Artists You Should Check Out

April is Jazz Appreciation Month, so we thought we'd celebrate by delving into the careers of a handful of underappreciated jazz artists. Explore the careers of six musicians who deserve more accolades and learn the best places to start with their discographies.

read more